“World's Most Complete Neighborpedia”
Explore:   What's happening in your neck of the woods?

SURVIVING SHARK ATTACKS IN THE HOUSING MARKET

There is a new predator lurking in the shallows of the Real Estate Market. First it was predatory lending practices, mostly on loans originated by the unscrupulous independent loan originators. They were soon consumed in a feeding frenzy as the bigger bank sharks began to come into the warm waters discovering the food source of consumable mortgages was a buffet.

If the experts are right... we are deep trouble. The Joint Economic Committee published their findings in October of 2007. The study concluded that foreclosures will impact the local economy, and foreclosures will continue to devalued personal housing wealth enjoyed by most Americans. American home owners are in fact being eaten alive by soaring debt as mortgages rates readjust and personal income does not.

"We estimate there will be approximately 1.3 million foreclosures and the loss of housing wealth of more than $103 BILLION through the end of 2009.... The total loss in property tax revenue amounting to more than $917 Million".

Florida holds the second highest rate of foreclosure filings in the Nation. Second to California. The current levels of unsold builder inventories are contributing to the food chain of Real Estate making it even more difficult for owners of resale properties to compete effectively. Purchasers who acquired their properties in 2004 or later, paid higher prices, and have little to no remaining equity in their property.

As priced declined, negative liquidity resulted. The value simply wasn't there any longer. Consumers first feared predatory lenders offering higher interest rates, in exchange for low or no income verification, were later treading water as the costs of home ownership, property taxes, insurance and utilities rose disproportionately to personal income. Pulling them into deeper water, and they struggled floundering in a sea of swelling increased expenses.

The loans were predicated on the assumption that property values would achieve a minimum appreciation over the two year reset time periods. Based on this assumption, lenders offered greater loan amounts enticing borrowers with favorable rates to borrow more and pay later.

 The predators are not the loan originators anymore. Most have been consumed by the Market already. The bigger fish, the banks and investment groups holding the mortgages have begun their feeding frenzy. The sharks are bearing down and consuming hundreds of thousands of homes like minnows in a shallow pond.

The Joint Economic Committee has made quantitative estimates indicating the potential magnitude of the rising scale of foreclosures and the cost impacts at the State and National levels. "We estimate there will be approximately 1.3 million foreclosures and a loss of housing wealth of more than $103 Billion through the end of 2009" The resulting loss in Property Tax Revenue is estimated to be $917 Million.

Moody's estimate in price declines is a modest 6.9%. If the price decline extends to 20% during that time period ending on the last quarter of 2009 the numbers increase exponentially to about 2 million foreclosures with property value losses estimated to be $106 Billion. The projected figures are conservative estimates assuming that all foreclosures over the 2007-2009 period come from the outstanding sub-prime mortgages of 2007.

The amount of sub prime loans originated in 2005 totalled $625 Billion or approximately 20% of the total loans. In 2006 another $600 Billion or 20% of all loans were sub-prime. Over this period the hybrid loans accounted for more than 72% of all sub-prime ARMS originated in 2005. An estimated 31% increase in payments is anticipated as these adjustable rates reset. "State and local governments will lose more than $917 Million in property tax revenue as a result of the destruction of housing wealth caused by sub prime foreclosures" the report stated.

Impacts on Communities Effected by Foreclosures

In Philadelphia a recent study by Shlay and Whitman found that abandoned property will lower property values on homes located within 150 feet by $7,627 or 0.1 percent, and will lower property values of homes located within 450 feet by 4.7% or $3,542. They found on average that one abandoned property on the block produced a decline of 9.1%. Where there were 5 abandoned properties on the block the decline on average resulted in 15%.

KEEPING THE SHARK FROM EATING YOU

Home Owners who purchased Property before 2004 are less likely to feel the bite of the bank. This predates hybrid loans and inflated adjustable rates. Prices of housing in 2004, made it possible for homeowners to have modest mortgages and still have equity in those properties despite the market decline and devaluation. Owners of properties purchased ten or more years ago, have achieved substantial equity and still have flexibility in their family budgets to sustain the decrease in recent market value.

Keep the banks from feeding on your home is a matter of taking a realistic assessment of your income, spending habits, and expenses. Trimming costs wherever possible. Put off purchasing anything expensive, and keep close watch on your credit cards. Usury rates are being imposed on late paying credit card customers often in the 30% range for as little as one missed or late payment. The average American currently has $15-20,000 in credit card debt. Once an introductory rate has been missed or is late, the bank has the right to readjust the rate of interest which often exceeds 15%-32% of total amount owed. Payments on a balance of $10,000 can be as high as $400 a month. Over a period of thirty years interest alone on a $9000 debt would be $18,000. Taking a big bite out of your paycheck. Consolidating and eliminating credit cards usage can save the average consumer thousands of dollars over the course of repaying the debt. Avoid paying the minimums if at all possible. Often the minimum payment will not cover the interest being charged on a monthly basis to your account.

EXPECT THE UNEXPECTED

Too often something unexpected will happen, and consumers are not prepared to deal with the financial aftermath of falling behind. Reserving an emergency fund even if it is only a few dollars a month can help to stave off hungry banks in an economic recession.

Create a Working Budget.

Factors to Consider. How much money do you bring home weekly after taxes? Knowing exactly how much money comes into the household will help create a solid foundation from which the basic necessities can be paid from.

Housing, utilities and food. Eliminating all extras will create additional supplemental money to pay bills with. Making a monthly list of what is owed and to whom helps in the practice of budgeting available funds.

SELL OFF UNUSED ITEMS

Garage sales, Yard sales, and consignment of unused items is an excellent way to generate additional income. Often treasures or former "must have" items are stockpiled in closets, garages and attics. A thorough clean out could help create catch up capital; which can be used to pay down existing debt. Effectively recycling stuff and cash in the process.

PREPARING FOR THE LONG HAUL

Waiting until the market stabilizes may be the best course of action for homeowners contemplating a move. The Government is considering Property Tax reforms for 2008, in addition to mandating banks to fix rates on sub prime loans in order to prevent the wide spread economic disaster from reaching fruition. Should this occur, borrowers who are current on their mortgage payments may receive some relief. Investors, however would not.

It is going to take time for the current inventories of homes on the Market to liquidate. St. Cloud, Florida Like most areas has a huge surplus of homes for sale including new construction, existing homes and investment properties. Buyers however, are in short supply at present. While growth in the area was estimated at 12% it appears to have equalized with retirees seeking greater value elsewhere and moving out of Florida in record numbers.

A greater economic base needs to be established in communities like St. Cloud, Florida. The Revenue base is not predicated on tourism, manufacturing or even Commerce. Subsequently, spending must also be reduced for non essential items until such time as the market recovers sufficiently to support the implementation of such expenditures. It is a precarious balancing act, however, elected officials as well as consumers must be diligent about how they spend the money they have in order for the Community at large to survive the arrival of the sharks.

Posted Friday Dec 14

Allison, this was an excellent post.  Your analogy of the market and the devouring sharks was right on.  You also give a very detailed analysis of the situation and provide a game plan of action.  Very well done!

Allison, I want to be just like you when I grow up. Smart and soooooo good looking:)

This is an excellent summary of our current market conditions. I fear 2008 is going to be a long difficult row to hoe. It should be very challenging for homowners and our economy.

Well done Allison!!

Allison,

What a great read! It is so sad that there is always a new influx of predators on the rise.

It is even sadder to think about familes with their life ahead of them, and younger children, having to sell everything because someone took advantage of them.

Merry Christmas to you.

Sincerely

Tom Braatz

Thanks You Lola!  I appreciate that you have been reading my stuff for a while now and I enjoy reading yours as well.

Broker Bryant.... WOW!  What a nice thing to say!  You are soooo sweet!

Tom- Thank you.  As BB and I know- it is going to get really ugly out there next year as well. However, once the feeding frenzy is over and the banks are bloated with unsellable houses, the market will eventually stabilize.   In the meantime, we can only do the best we can given what we've got.  May your holidays be filled with joy and in the company of those you love.

 

Thanks Allison! Great post. Poeple really need to take a step back and create a game plan for them that will work instead of giving up. You have given some great tips here and real advice.

-Joey

AWESOME POST ALLISON...I really enjoyed reading the solid information that you have provided....Good luck next year and Happy Holidays......

SEE YOU AT THE TOP!!!!

 

Oscar 

 

 

(12/15/07 10:37PM) — Kevin Whitty

Well, all I can say is Thanks .  What an informative post .   

Thanks, great post!

(12/16/07 08:35AM) — Perrin Cornell, ABR

OK, the advice part is excellent... at any time!

As to the rest...well for starters I have NEVER and I mean never read an economic catastrophic forecast that was ever close to the mark... especially on the gloom and doom side (they don't call economics the dismal science for nothing). Next, about the time everyone is saying the "sky is falling" is about the time things are changing (so too with the mantra there is no top to the upside and everyone should jump in). You can count for sure that when the government steps in things are already going the other way. Finally, really no offense, but this is pretty much old news.

Unfortunately, people that bought the bonds secured by the mortgages will suffer, banks are rapidly writing down earnings and literally dozens of ideas are being floated and implemented to shore up the system. While I don't doubt your numbers, the actual percentage of the total mortgages in the system effected is around 2% or less... looks like 2007 will go down as the 4th or 5th best year in sales history and i believe NAR economic guys are already talking that '08 rather than '09 will see the turnaround (hmmmm).... CA, FL, NV and a few spots in-between will suffer more because of excesses... but in all, this too shall pass. So I think I will have another cup of tea and read the tea leaves again, to see if things have changed yet.

Real Estate is local, out localmarket going bad affects us, I like to remind people that we have to work where we live..And we have to make the best out of wht we have to work with.....SOme of these homes will allow homebuyer hopefuls a chance in this upcoming market...there is always someone benifiting from the upside of the market, whether it be stocks, real estate  or  potatoes

(12/16/07 10:20PM) — Bob & Karen Winney

Our market in Kansas City has not been trounced as hard as many in the country but nonetheless, the tide of foreclosures is one of the factors that has affected us. It sure doesn't seem like it is about to slow down anytime soon.

We have started picking up a few short sales and it seems like an opportunity to make lemonade from the lemons we have been dealt.

Good luck in 08!

(12/16/07 10:26PM) — Vincent Ambrose

Very cleverly written!  I loved it!

Allison, This blog is entertaining and packed with good information. I am going to bookmark this for my archives! Thanks and Merry Christmas. Deb

Allison, This blog is entertaining and packed with good information. I am going to bookmark this for my archives! Thanks and Merry Christmas. Deb

Thanks Deb- I am glad you enjoyed it. It may not be all sunshine and roses, however, knowing what is concerning the government, will lead to change economic and otherwise. 

 

Collin- Thanks for your input and comment.  We can only wait and see what transpires and which measures are effective and which ones are not. 

The problem is compounded here in Florida where impact fees tripled, Property Taxes spiked rising over 30% , and local government spending too much based on tax revenue not yet collected.  Like everyone else, I want to see the correction rebound but in Florida Real Estate transactions have dropped 67%.  That is a staggering amount.  We are perhaps more suseptible due to the transient nature of our buyers.  Foreign buyers, vacation buyers, relocation buyers, and time share as well. Which may not be the case in other parts of the country. Let's hope it improves sooner than projected.

 

Thanks Alma- I appreciate your comment.

Mike- we can only hope the turn around comes soon!

More and more we see clients coming to us to help them out of precarious situations, sometimes we can and other times we cannot as they are in debt too deeply.  What I am watching are the areas where multiple foreclosures are occuring, as this does and will impact the value of the surrounding homes.  As one foreclosures and is sacraficed, the sale of such a property establishes a new "market value"  and appraisals are based on sold properties which impact tax revenue much in the same way.

The majority of these foreclosed properties have not achieved a sale however, which means they are still on the balance sheets of investors stock portfolios at full market value, which is no longer achievable.  When these losses are reported and they bad loans are written off the books will the real damage come to light.

 

(12/17/07 10:52PM) — Christopher Nitchoff

This was a great post. Too bad not everyone is looking out for other peoples best interests.Instead they put themselves first. Which is the complete opposite of customer service.

(12/18/07 02:54PM) — Real Estate Latino

you know, I work to prevent predatory lending practices every day in my community and I don't like the idea to associate sharks (the fish) with unscrupulous human beings. Sharks along already have "mala fama" bad fame and are being over killed across the world, lets not give people another excuse to kill a shark.

Bill Arce

www.realestatelatino.co

I do feel for the communities in Florida and California that are being hit the hardest but I also have to wonder what they were thinking, if they were thinking at all.  The appreciations were out of control.  Hopefully we will all learn from this so it doesn't happen again.

Great Post.  I have been working in the Foreclosure market for years now and this is by far the worst it has ever been.  The government is starting to take action and just like Realtors, the mortgage industry will become regulated and held accountable for their lending practices!  When people lose money, change happens...it's unfortunate that so many homeowners have to suffer in order to better our lending systems.

Post a comment

Temporarily disabled — coming soon!