What fun! A hearty welcome to NCAR Form 770!
Often when I see a group of people squirm, I start to grin, and I had that opportunity over the last couple of months when contemplating the new NCREC rule regarding Additional Compensation Disclosure.
Squirm.... Squirm... GRIN! GRIN!
Gosh, what a low blow! Now an agent has to disclose in writing (writhing?) any co-broke or agent bonus above a negotiated "baseline" prior to the client entering the decision-making process on a property. This mostly impacts Buyers' Agents, due to the nature of co-brokes and bonuses. It is uncommon, although possible, for the Buyer to pay the Listing Agent, and that would likely require disclosure, too.
Revised NCAR Standard Form 201, Exclusive Right to Represent Buyer, requires in Section 4 for the Buyers' Agent to negotiate and establish with the Buyer an expected level of Agent compensation. The "baseline." Then, in Section 4(b)ii, the Agent and Buyer indicate whether the Buyer will compensate the Agent for any shortfall in compensation below that "baseline."
Should a Listing Agent offer a bonus or higher co-broke to a Buyers' Agent, the Buyers' Agent must disclose the dollar value of the additional inducement prior to the client entering the decision-making process. This requirement includes the estimated value of trips, cruises, etc, that an agent can earn via multiple sales in a neighborhood. That cruise value must be at least verbally disclosed to all clients the agent brings during the promotion. The disclosure will be documented in writing prior to writing an offer.
Offering a referral to another agent? North Carolina now requires the referring agent to disclose the referral fee. That may help an agent reconsider shopping clients for the highest fee, rather than for the best agent fit.
If you like the lunch money kickback you get from the home warranty company, you can still get it. You will disclose that payment to your client. Gee. Maybe we will have fewer listing agents fighting tooth and nail to order a warranty the week before closing, when it has no bearing on the transaction, no value going forward for their Sellers, and they have to sell the kickback to their clients so they can keep the lunch money.
Driven by a scandal wherein a builder paid bribes under the table to an agency in violation of RESPA and all that is holy there, this rule will generate tons of fun.
We are seeing Buyer Agent bonuses as high as $10,000 (And rumor is they are as high as $50,000--$60,000 in the NC Mountains) and co-brokes as high as 8% in the Raleigh Cary area. The inducements to neglect the fiduciary duty and to put the agent first can be difficult to withstand. This disclosure rule hits us at a good time.
That's my story, and I'm sticking with it!
ActiveRain Corp. is not responsible for the accuracy of the site's content (which is written by members of the ActiveRain Real Estate Network) and does not endorse the views of the real estate agents, mortgage brokers, and others listed here.
Powered by the ActiveRain Real Estate Network
© 2009 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved
Hi Mike, It sounds like it will keep everyone honest. In our area BTSA's were a big thing but now they have to be disclosed and I don't see them as much. I am always going to negotiate the best price for my client so when I saw them I knew I had that much room to work with. What REALLY got me were the ones who advertised we will give ___ BTSA with a full price offer.
Hey, Marchel!
I wish all it took was paperwork to make an honest world.... :D
That "full price offer" offer is a little offensive, isn't it?
Mike,
This is pretty interesting stuff. Thanks for sticking to your story. LOL
Mike in Tucson
Disclosure is very important. I wonder why they don't reduce the price instead of giving large bonuses.
Mike,
You got it!
Gita,
Often Builders will offer incentives to Buyers and/or agents to maintain their price point rather than lower the comps for the neighborhood. And some Sellers know that they can get more agents' attention, and possibly a compromise of their fiduciary duty, by offering bonuses rather than a lower price. So... Now we have mandatory disclosure of compensation to the client.
Hey Mike,
I know you and I know you're a good and honest man. Like me, you probably show your buyers the MLS sheets disclosing to them the compensation anyway. This proves you have your client's best interests at hand as you don't steer them to a specific property because of a "bonus" or higher payout.
For those who aren't as honest, the new form will keep them walking the straight and narrow.
As far as referring agents shopping for the best deal instead of the best agent for their clients.....that's another story!
Great post.
Hope all is well in Jaquish land!
Craig,
I have coffee. Life is good. Thanks for the kind words!
Hey, Mike - I think NC is doing a great thing. Folks that want to will always find a way to focus on themselves and not the client... but this disclosure is a great move. It's all about empowering the consumer and that can't bad.
Jesse,
I think you are right. Obviously.