About Key West's Old Town

Expect the unexpected if you are looking to buy a place in Key West. And I'm not referring to prices or structural problems. Here are some examples of what you may encounter when you look at property. All examples are true.

Newton Street Station was an all male guest house located in the Meadows Area of Key West. I mentioned to an agent in my office that I was going to show it. She told me to warn my customers to expect to see the manager open the door and assist in showing the property in the nude. She was serious. So I told my customers. They were gay and took it in stride. And I showed it several more times to gay and straight buyers. The guy was always nude. I had a listing on another guest house and was showing it when the buyers' agent mentioned he was going to show Newton Street Station next. I warned him about the naked manager. A few days later he saw me and thanked me. He had warned his straight Midwest couple and they took it is stride.

I remember showing a little cottage home owned by two older gay men in the Meadows Area. It looked as if every single foot of the house had a picture of a naked man or a sculpture of the male form. Each of the tiny rooms was filled with male art. The listing agent finally convinced the owners to remove some of the art so that potential buyers could see beyond the clutter. He told me he removed boxes and boxes of it. I showed the same house about a year ago and remember never having seen that the house was in such bad condition.

A guy I knew from my gym asked me to discuss listing his condo. When I walked into his living room the first thing I saw was a huge oil painting of him in the nude. I suggested that he remove it so that buyers would focus on the room rather than on his body.

A couple of weeks ago another agent was showing my clients and me around his listing in Bahama Village. The house is tenant occupied so we had to look in the late afternoon. One girl was still asleep in one bedroom. (That happens many times.) The agent knocked on the other bedroom door. No answer so we went inside and looked around and talked for at least two minutes. Then he opened the door to the bathroom. The startled European boy had just gotten out of the shower. Oops.

If you are looking at a house or apartment that is inhabited by long time locals you will probably see Fantasy Fest beads and cute photos that adorn the walls. And every once in a while you may find some awfully large sized stilettos and wigs.

If you are looking for a home in the Old Town area of Key West CLICK HERE to checkout several homes priced under $999,000. Several are under $600,000. The market is in a state of flux right now and sellers are anxious to sell. You might find something you actually like and want to buy. Please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com to take a look. I'll be sure to Knock three times before we enter.

I have written many times about Old Town being the place to buy if you are looking for top value both short term and long term. And I've said that certain blocks within Old Town are more valuable than others. Proximity to certain locations or the "look" of certain blocks seems to create or enhance value among nearby homes. But most properties in Old Town are priced higher than many would-be buyers can pay or are willing to pay for a second or third home. So what's a prospective buyer to do?

I suggest that you Buy Value by purchasing the best property in an area that is not as popular as Old Town but is located nearby! Or Buy Value by buying top quality property that is under priced even though the price is higher than you think you can afford.

CLICK HERE for some examples. I picked properties priced between $1.8 - $2.3 million, but you can use our Key West Association of Realtors mls search engine CLICK HERE to search properties in your own price range to find properties that may meet your needs. I always suggest that you search prices higher than you think you want to pay (sales prices are usually lower than asking price) and reduce your size requirements. Be flexible. Be forward looking. Believe that America will comeback.

823 White Street is a large renovation on a busy street during the daytime, but generally quite in the evening and on weekends. This large property is priced at $568 per sq ft compared to similar properties around $900 - $1000 in the heart of Old Town.

822 Washington is in Casa Marina and for blocks to the Atlantic Ocean. Very large contemporary property and value priced at $636 per sq ft. Other area homes are in the $800+ per sq ft range.

727 Waddell is new construction also in Casa Marina area near the Casa Marina Hotel and beach. This house is new and has everything. Priced at $714 per sq ft. This house should be in the $1000 per sq ft range.

806 Truman is obviously located on busy Truman Avenue. This gracious early 20th century historical home has been tastefully updated and is a real beauty. Two guest guest houses make this a great retreat for some buyer with lots of friends and family. Priced at $805 per sq ft. This house is priced right for size and location, but the house has way more going for it than just about any similarly priced house. The location is killing the value, not the house itself.

410 Simonton is a dollhouse right in the heart of Old Town. What a beauty. Price at $388 per sq ft. Busy location during the day, but generally quiet at night.

315 Peacon Lane is priced at $828 per sq ft for a beauty on a very quiet lane in a dynamic location very near the Historic Seaport yet far enough away not to be part of the noise and hubub. This house is probably priced about $100 per sq ft under market.

716 Olivia is a stunning renovation that got derailed by the downturn in the market. Short sale offered at $844 per sq ft. Custom everything. You will get total quality and beautiful design on this babe. I think a sharp buyer may be able to swing a good deal on this one.

Finally, I need to strongly recommend that buyers look at 409 Williams Street. Priced at $769 per sq ft but should be priced around $1000 - $1100. This is a prime example of my recommendation to "Buy Value by buying top quality property that is under priced even though the price is higher than you think you can afford." There are too many homes in the $1000 and up price range. The seller really wants to sell. And the as offered now is basically what the seller paid for the house before all of the dramatic renovations were made. The seller did not pay too much for the property. But he really wants to sell it now. This is a deal not to be missed.

Give me, Gary Thomas, a call to see one of these houses, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. A few years from now people will be kicking themselves in the rear end for not having bought some of these homes at the value price offered today. That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

Two bedroom, one bath Old Town home at a very reasonable price. This Conch home is in great condition and has had many recent upgrades including central A/C, new roof, electric and plumbing, foundation. No spongy floors here! All the major work has been done. Lovely covered deck, fenced yard, and open kitchen/dining area. Room for a pool, too!
Listing #105694 Beds: 2 Baths: 1 (1 0) (FH)
$395,000 (LP)

The asking price just got a lot better on 421-423 Simonton Street in the very heart of Old Town Key West. This property is the ugliest of ducks in Old Town. But the location is just about as good as it gets. The property is ripe for renovation and the new asking price makes that prospect of renovation more realistic.

421 Simonton was originally listed in April 2006 at $2,299,999. It didn't sell, and the price has been sporadically reduced on March 4th. The new price is $1,350,000. This is what you get for the money: 3766 sq ft building on a 3520 sq ft lot. There are 5 ROGO UNITS WITH TRANSIENT LICENSING plus 2 retail stores on the ground floor located one block from Duval. Possible Guesthouse or Condo conversion. Renovation project with lots of potential. Room for a pool. CLICK HERE for details offered by the listing realtor.

The current facade is hideous and probably dates to the 1950s. But behind the facade is what appears to be a big old Key West conch house. I say "appears" because I have only been inside the front building which housed an antique store. But the property behind the facade is what restorers want. This property will take some digging and investigating. But my suspicion is that you will find interesting photos of the building at the Monroe County Library. You can then develop a plan to renovate the building and make maximum use of the land and space. Perhaps you can use the 5 transient licenses to create a small boutique guest house with a pool. If you are a repressed innkeeper at heart this may be your opportunity to create your own very special guest house. And that location would be a killer!

I think a serious renovation project would also get the cooperation of the Historic Architectural Review Commission (HARC). The building next door to the south is an antique store and just underwent a restoration of its facade. Its picture at night is featured above.

Want to buy commercial space in Key West? CLICK HERE to do your own personal search of the Key West mls website. If you see something you like, please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. Let me know the mls property number and let me know how I can help you. Even if what you want is not listed does not mean it may not be available. Let me know what you are looking for and maybe I can find it. Commercial sales have not been going very well and there may be a willingness on the part of some sellers to negotiate now more readily than they would have done in the past. You never know until you try.

When the weather up north makes the evening news I always thank God I moved to Key West. The snowstorm and tornadoes that hit the Midwest last week were devastating, and I make no joke about that.

I lived in Colorado for all of my life until I moved to Key West in December 1993. I remember many times when the thermometer hit 20 below zero and I would have to get up a couple of times during the night to start the car just to make sure it would start the next morning. I had a huge front sidewalk that I got to shovel. The heavy Denver snowstorms started to take their toll on me.

It started snowing like hell the afternoon before I left Denver to head to New York City in passage to Key West. (I had to be somewhere while my furniture was in transit to the Keys.) New York City was just as cold as Denver, but there wasn't any snow.

Three days after I left Denver and three days before Christmas I arrived in Key West. It was like 80 degrees and sunny. You know you're here when you get off the plane and walk into the humidity. Even if it isn't humid, the air smells different. And if you have ever been to Key West before you immediately feel "I'm back!" And you thank the Lord for Key West.

Key West has changed in the past 15 years, mostly for the better. Things have certainly got more expensive. Of course real estate has gone up, gone down, and gone sideways. The cost of rental housing has just gone up. The cost of a beer in the bars on Duval has zoomed way out of proportion. The cheap meals at Wendy's do not exist in Key West. But the cheap meals at TGI Fridays do exist. Gas costs way more here than it should, but the gas companies get away with it because they can. I hardly ever go shopping because stuff doesn't matter any more. I have what I need. Besides shopping at Ross isn't exactly like going to Bloomingdales or Macys. Heck, we don't even have Target or a GAP.

But in spite of the high prices and lack of shopping, life in Key West is much simpler and easier than it was up north. And when the need arises I can always get in a car or take an airplane back to reality.

And that reminds me that almost every night there is some story about some horrible event or odd thing that occurred somewhere in Florida. Thank God Key West is not part of Florida. Our weather is different than the weather in Miami. Our people are most certainly different. We don't have home invasions and murders at convenience stores. Most people don't lock their doors. Really.

My only regret about moving to Key West is that it took me so long to do it. So those of you coping with the bad weather up north just remember there's snow place like home. Want to move here, call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. CLICK HERE to checkout these single family homes in or near Old Town for under $699,000.