

I have received dozens of phone calls from California home owners as a result of my post Clarification Regarding California Non-Recourse mortgages.
Based on these phone conversations, I have come to the conclusion that there is a very frightening trend: real estate professionals (both loan officers and real estate agents) are offering advice based on "real estate urban legends" i.e. information that has been passed from person to person and is treated FACT but is completely unsubstantiated.
Three examples of these calls are:
A homeowner has lost 60% of the value on his investment property which has negative cash flow. The mortgages (a 1st and 2nd) were refinanced so they are no longer non-recourse. He doesn't have a hardship situation. His loan officer told him to to stop making the payments and let the home go to foreclosure to get out from under the mortgage debt. Urban legend advice. Foreclosure will release him from the obligation to repay on the 1st mortgage only (assumed to be the foreclosing lender) but the 2nd lienholder will have the right to collect a whopping $180k for up to four years - and they are pursuing these collections.
A homeowner with a valid hardship is selling his home as a short-sale. The home had been refinanced multiple times with some level of cash-out each time. His real estate agent told him not to worry about income taxes on the deficiency because "there is a federal law that says he doesn't have to pay". Again, urban legend advice. The Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act very clearly states that income taxes don't have to be paid on the "acquisition indebtedness" for a primary home. Income taxes DO have to be paid for the unpaid balance above the original purchase mortgage. In this case, the amount of phantom income will be over $250k.
Another homeowner with a short-sale. The approval clearly states that the 2nd lienholder retains their right to collect the balance due. The real estate agent told him not to worry about it. If the lender tries to collect, he can always file bankruptcy. Urban legend advice. In California, you must pass a "means test" to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy if you earn in excess of approx. $75k per year. Most people will not pass the means test without their mortgage and will be forced in to a Chapter 13 bankruptcy (repayment plan).
To be treated as professionals, we must act as professionals. Due dilligence and research on the information we offer as fact should be the bare minimum standard of conduct. Equally important, clients making these crucial decisions should be emphatically urged to consult with the appropriate legal and tax professionals or the financial repurcussions could be devasting.
Wendy Cutrufelli
Your Real Estate Advocate
I shudder when I read blanket statements that California mortgages are Non-Recourse. Why do I shudder? Because people BELIEVE IT and are making decisions about whether to let their home go to foreclosure based on an incomplete understanding of the facts.

So what ARE the facts?
Under California law, a mortgage debt is considered "non-recourse" when the mortgage was made under the following two circumstances:
- The mortgage was made to purchase a 1 - 4 unit property and the borrower occupies at least one of the units.
- The Seller financing for all or a portion of the purchase price of the property.
A mortgage with Recourse is one in which neither of the above two exemptions applies. Examples of recourse debt are:
Given the previous run-up of property values combined with low interest rates, the number of people who DIDN'T refinance their homes and, in many cases, add a Home Equity Line of Credit is extremely low. Only those owner-ocuppant homeowners who retained their purchase money mortgage(s) on their primary residence have non-recourse debt, everyone else has recourse debt.
The second important part of this recourse equation:
Homeowners should always consult with an attorney regarding their personal situation.

As a proud Clayton, California resident and a Realtor, I am pleased to announce the new Clayton community website: EverythingClayton.com
This website was designed as a centralized internet site to bring all of the community resources together:
ActiveRain Corp. is not responsible for the accuracy of the site's content (which is written by members of the ActiveRain Real Estate Network) and does not endorse the views of the real estate agents, mortgage brokers, and others listed here.
Powered by the ActiveRain Real Estate Network
© 2009 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved